On this week’s episode, Nick and Amanda reveal their ignorance for past lip sync songs as they read their Lip Sync Sorter results. Amanda taps into the paranormal and spots a ghost lurking behind Nick as they record. The hosts come to the realization that Tammy Brown is the true All Star of the season. The After Hours segment turns into a boozy impromptu sing-a-long including the opening number of Ragtime and a rousing rendition of the podcast’s new theme song.